Album Review: Pretty Baby – Layaway Plot

Album Review: Pretty Baby – Layaway Plot

Published On: April 29th, 2026|

Blackened and melodic, Layaway Plot – the new album from Pretty Baby – stares death in the face without flinching even once.

From its roots as a concept-based solo project for Charlotte, North Carolina vocalist and guitarist Rusty Colton in 2016, Pretty Baby expanded to a full band. While the original idea behind Pretty Baby was to portray a drug-addled and washed-up rockstar, the band found that the nature of live performance changed the sonic dynamics and, soon, subject matter.

That’s not to say that Layaway Plot is an easy listen: the album found its genesis in the aftereffects of Colton’s mother passing in 2023. The title came from the band’s bassist, Lenny, when talking about how capitalism impacts managing bereavement on a practical level when still hurting.

That certainly made an impression on me, having grown up in an environment where funerals were paid for in advance, sometimes by instalments, or quietly funded by family and community. That kind of exposure to grief, the nature of society, and dealing with all that turmoil and responsibility – and what would otherwise be normal life changes too, but are now magnified – is the angry engine that powers Layaway Plot.

The album is flawless; there is no weakness here, just the tumult of confusion, clarity, and lack of closure that often typifies grief. Time doesn’t heal; it just dulls the pain until it charges back into your consciousness, fresh and raw.

I would single out one song, though, as having made the greatest emotional impact on me. Sleepdrunk is a killer of a track: hard as nails and an arrangement that is unforgiving and manic, suddenly collapsing into near quiet, the vocals full of uncertainty before expressing a howl of sheer rage, fuelled by pain. It arrives upon the dominant musical strands within the album: (post-)hardcore, alt-rock, and post-punk, though the latter two are supporting players to the album’s emotional and sonic feralness.

Layaway Plot was released on the 3rd of April via a triumvirate of labels: Expert Work Records of Columbia, Missouri; The Ghost Is Clear Records of Kansas City, Missouri; and Mishap Records of Boise, Idaho.

Album Review: Pretty Baby – Layaway Plot

The album can be purchased on Bandcamp in digital format, as well as on limited-edition black vinyl. The band has just finished a tour in support of the LP: for details on upcoming live dates and options to listen to their music, follow Pretty Baby on Instagram.

Discover more great music

About the Author: Mark Buckley

Blogger, AnalogueTrash co-owner. Mainly talks about cats, favourite varieties of tofu, and the history of Nightwish.